Three Men, One Moment: What Pipp, Gehrig, and Dahlgren Teach Us About Life’s Turning Points
Three books can change your Thursday. One book can change your world.
Hello,
This is a story of three men whose lives became interlinked–unexpectedly, unintentionally, and unavoidably.
None of them planned it.
None of them saw it coming.
And yet, one would not have become who he was without the other.
Let me take you back to May 2, 1939, in Detroit.
Wally Pipp–a former New York Yankee, now a sports columnist for the Detroit Times–sat alone in the bleachers at Briggs Stadium. He was there to work. To watch the Yankees play the Tigers. To take notes. Just another game in a long baseball season.
But before the first pitch, he saw something he knew was not ordinary.
Lou Gehrig walked up to his manager, Joe McCarthy, said a few quiet words, and handed over his glove. No ceremony. No announcement. No explanation. Just a small gesture that told the entire truth: he couldn’t go today.
Gehrig, the Iron Horse, was taking himself out of the lineup.
For the first time in 2,130 games.
And then a young first baseman jogged onto the field to replace him.
Babe Dahlgren.
As the crowd murmured, Pipp felt something stir inside him. A recognition. A memory of a moment he lived himself fourteen years earlier.
See, from 1915 to 1925, Wally Pipp had been the Yankees’ anchor at first base. Ten straight seasons. Twice the league’s home run champion. Three World Series appearances. A player teammates trusted and fans knew by name.
And on June 2, 1925, he walked into Yankee Stadium expecting to play, just as he had for a decade. Same routine. Same position. Same life.
Except that morning, he had a pounding headache he couldn’t ignore.
So he did something small. Something that felt harmless.
He told his manager, Miller Huggins, “Bench me today.”
Huggins nodded, looked down the bench, and said to a young, unproven player who had appeared in fewer than 25 major-league games:
“Gehrig - take first today.”
Pipp didn’t know it then, but he had just played his final game as the Yankees’ starting first baseman. And Gehrig–quiet, humble, unassuming–never left the lineup again… until this precise moment in 1939, the moment Pipp was now watching unfold before his eyes in Detroit.
From his seat in the stands, Pipp watched Dahlgren take the same position he once held, after the same quiet exchange that had changed his own career. He watched Gehrig sit on the bench–hands folded, eyes forward–just as he had.
And he understood something simple and honest:
This is how it goes.
One day you step in.
One day you carry the responsibility.
And one day you step aside.
All three men were living different parts of the same story:
Pipp - letting go.
Gehrig - enduring.
Dahlgren - beginning.
The field didn’t change.
The game didn’t change.
Only the names did.
Pipp stayed in his seat until the last out. He watched the grounds crew rake the dirt around first base, smoothing the footprints–Gehrig’s and Dahlgren’s–erasing them to prepare for tomorrow.
He stood, took one last look at the field, and walked out of the stadium.
Not defeated. Not nostalgic.
Just clear-eyed about how this all works.
Everyone gets their innings.
Some long. Some short.
But none of them last forever.
Welcome to this week’s Three Book Thursday.
1. Personal development
How to Stop Worrying and Start Living: Time-Tested Methods for Conquering Worry
Summary
Dale Carnegie’s How to Stop Worrying and Start Living offers a simple but powerful idea: worry doesn’t protect us—it drains us. It pulls us out of the present, fills our minds with imagined disasters, and convinces us that spiraling thoughts somehow count as preparation.
Carnegie cuts through that noise with clear, practical principles. Live in “day-tight compartments.” Focus on the small slice of time you can actually influence. Accept what you can’t change so you can finally work on what you can. Ask what the worst outcome might be, make peace with it, and then start improving it.
His stories remind us that worry rarely changes outcomes—but it always changes us. It shrinks our days, narrows our perspective, and steals the energy we need to live fully.
This isn’t a book about eliminating uncertainty. It’s a guide for staying steady inside it. A blueprint for returning to center when your mind is running ahead or replaying the past. A reminder that clarity lives in action, not rumination.
At its core, How to Stop Worrying and Start Living is about reclaiming the moments we lose to fear. It’s about presence, calm, and the discipline of meeting each day as it comes.
Not to avoid worry entirely—but to stop letting it write the story.
Quote: “Remember, today is the tomorrow you worried about yesterday.”
Principle: Cooperate with the inevitable.
Insight: One of the most tragic things I know about human nature is that all of us tend to put off living.
Author: Dale Carnegie
Themes: Personal development
My personal notes from the book
2. Biography
Tiger Woods
Summary
Jeff Benedict’s Tiger Woods isn’t just the story of a prodigy—it’s the story of what happens when a life is engineered for greatness before a child even understands what greatness is. Tiger was built through repetition, precision, and an almost unthinkable level of parental pressure and structure. His rise wasn’t luck; it was deliberate, disciplined, and often isolating. Benedict shows how mastery can become both a superpower and a burden—fueling historic dominance while quietly narrowing a life until performance becomes identity.
And when that identity cracked, the fall was catastrophic. Tiger’s collapse wasn’t a celebrity scandal—it was the unraveling of someone who had never been taught how to be human. Someone designed to win but not to fail. Someone who could handle pressure but not pain. And yet, that breakdown created space for transformation. The comeback—culminating in the 2019 Masters—wasn’t about golf. It was about reconstruction: confronting pain honestly, rebuilding relationships, relearning vulnerability, and rediscovering a version of himself that wasn’t tethered solely to results.
In the end, Tiger Woods becomes a story about ambition, consequences, and renewal. It’s a reminder that success built on perfection is fragile, but success built on growth endures. And it challenges us to look at our own pursuits—where discipline serves us, where it confines us, and what it means to rise again after everything has fallen apart.
Quote: “The first thing I taught Tiger, aside from the love of the golf game, was the love of practice.”
Principle: From childhood, perfection wasn’t the goal — it was the requirement.
Insight: Redemption began the moment he admitted he needed rebuilding.
Author: Jeff Benedict
Themes: Biography, Sports
My personal notes from the book
3. Memoir
Singular Intimacies: Becoming a Doctor at Bellevue
Summary
Danielle Ofri’s Singular Intimacies captures the reality of medicine in a way few books ever do. Bellevue isn’t just a hospital—it’s a world unto itself, a place where intensity, chaos, and humanity collide every hour of every day. As someone who completed residency at Bellevue, I feel a kinship with anyone who has walked those halls. It was the most formative time of my life—surrounded by brilliant colleagues, unforgettable patients, and the kind of life-and-death moments that shape who you become forever. So whenever a book is set at Bellevue, I devour it. And Ofri delivers insights that feel personal, familiar, and deeply true.
What makes this book powerful is how it strips medicine down to its core: connection. Not the cleaned-up version most people imagine, but the raw, unfiltered intimacy of being allowed into someone’s life at their most vulnerable. Ofri shows how the smallest interactions—a moment of stillness, a quiet admission, a shared breath in a crisis—can leave a lasting imprint on a young physician. These stories remind us that becoming a doctor isn’t a series of milestones; it’s a series of relationships. Every patient leaves a mark, whether we realize it at the time or not.
But Singular Intimacies goes beyond medicine. It’s about being present. About noticing. About slowing down long enough to actually hear the stories unfolding in front of you. It’s a reminder that growth doesn’t come from the big achievements—it comes from being willing to sit in uncertainty, to care deeply, to let experiences change you. Whether you’re in medicine, business, leadership, or simply trying to live with more intention, this book pulls you back to what matters: the human moments. The connection. The honesty. The small encounters that quietly shape the person you become.
At its heart, Ofri’s book reminds us that the real work of any meaningful life isn’t about perfection—it’s about presence. It’s about letting people in. And it’s about allowing the moments that move us—especially the difficult ones—to become the experiences that define us.
Quote: “Medicine is a front-row seat to the full range of human experience.”
Principle: Vulnerability is what allows a doctor to truly connect.
Insight: Every patient carries a story far deeper than the diagnosis.
Author: Danielle Ofri
Themes: Memoir, Patient care, Residency training
My personal notes from the book
If there’s a thread running through Wally Pipp, Lou Gehrig, Babe Dahlgren, Dale Carnegie, Tiger Woods, and Danielle Ofri, it’s this: our lives are shaped not by the moments we plan, but by the ones that force us to change.
Pipp didn’t intend to step aside.
Gehrig didn’t expect his endurance to end.
Dahlgren didn’t ask to inherit a legend’s shadow.
And yet each man learned the same quiet truth: every season of life asks something different of us. Sometimes we’re rising. Sometimes we’re carrying the weight. Sometimes we’re letting go. But in every season, we’re being shaped.
Carnegie shows us that worry steals those seasons before we ever live them.
Tiger’s story reveals how ambition without presence breaks us, and how rebuilding begins the moment we stop pretending we’re invincible.
Bellevue teaches that the most meaningful growth happens in the small, unplanned moments—when we slow down long enough to notice the people right in front of us.
So the question isn’t which season you’re in.
The real question is: Are you actually living it?
Are you present for the innings you’ve been given?
Are you willing to evolve when life hands you a moment you didn’t ask for?
Are you paying attention to the quiet exchanges—the ones that seem small but turn out to be everything?
Because one day you’re Pipp.
One day you’re Gehrig.
One day you’re Dahlgren.
And your life—your real life—is happening in the space between those roles.
If there’s something to take from this week’s books, it’s this:
Show up fully wherever you are. Let each season shape you. And when the moment comes to step in, step up, or step aside—do it with presence, humility, and courage.
Your innings won’t last forever.
But what you do with them will.
Always ❤️📚💡
Three Book Thursday is free, but there are many costs to create these posts each week. So, can you do me a favor?
If you find value here, please support the newsletter.
Please share Three Book Thursday with a friend, college, family member, or post it to your socials. I’m working hard to grow this audience, but let’s be honest—you’re probably better at it than I am.
Or, do both!
Loved today’s commentary! Very thought provoking. Happy Thanksgiving to all of you! 🥰By the way, love the chocolate you recommended